Colombia-British woman who has been attributed to millions of dollars to help care for his son, brain damage will have to return to court to try to get the money because in the trial, the judge has plagiarized most of his decisiona superior court.
Monica Cojocaru has received more than 5 million in April 2009 after successfully in the Colombia of British Columbia women's Hospital and its medical staff negligence at the birth of his son.
The child, Eric Cojocaru, was left with permanent brain damage after a birth complicated in 2001.
The Supreme Court of British Columbia Colombia Justice Joel Groves used more than 100 pages to expose its decision, including the criticism of three doctors involved in the birth, Groves said had not properly informed of the mother of potential risks to the child.
However, two of the three judges on a panel of the Court of appeal of British Columbia decided Thursday that Groves copied, nearly Word for Word, most of its decision.
The Group found more than 300 368 paragraphs were almost identical to the comments made by counsel for the family Cojocaru.
In its decision, the Court of appeal stated reasons for judgment groves can be considered its own, does not meet the standard of public responsibility and do not allow a meaningful review.
"A reasonable and informed observer could not be satisfied that the trial judge considered all the evidence before him and made the appropriate conclusions," the Panel wrote.
The Court of Appeal ordered a new trial.
With Robert Zimmerman files back the CBC links to accessibility
没有评论:
发表评论